EIFF logo

Based on William Saroyen’s book ‘The Human Comedy’, the film is set in wartime Ithaca, New York. The only thing which would have made the superb sets and costumes more realistic would have been a sepia tint.

Homer Macaulay, the young protaganist, an excellent Alex Neustaedter, goes to work in the local telegraph office after the death of his father, to help support his mother (Meg Ryan), sister and brother.  His older brother has just gone off to war and writes him long, frank, supportive letters.  To his horror, part of Homer’s job is to deliver letters of condolence from the War Office, informing families of the death of their loved ones: in fact his first such job involves actually reading the telegram to the mother.

Sam Shepard excels as a crusty, drunken old telegraph operator and Tom Hanks cameos as Homer’s dead father.  [tweet_box design=”default”]Meg Ryan’s directorial debut is a fine film which tells an interesting story but comes a little unstuck with one or two of the narrative details.[/tweet_box]

+ posts

Mary is a longstanding writer with publications in The Scotsman and a number of independent travel logs and blogs. She has written professionally as part of her 40 year career in education and for pleasure.